Are the 5 Stages of Grief Misinterpreted?

By: Matthew Funeral Home
Thursday, April 27, 2023

In 1969, Dr. Elisabeth Kubler-Ross developed the concept of the 5 stages of grief. First appearing in her book, On Dying and Death, the process of grief was conceptualized as how the body reacts to death. Since then, the 5 stages have been popularized and have become a part of how most Americans understand grieving loss. Below, we will discuss the importance of the 5 stages in our grief culture, and what we can do to remedy this. 

What are the 5 Stages of Grief?

The 5 stages of grief are Denial, Anger, Bargaining, Depression, and Acceptance. Generally, the understanding is that one moves from stage to stage as one continues to develop feelings of grief. Unfortunately, this can cause some issues in how some people interpret grief after a loss. Some people do not experience anger and think they are grieving wrong. Some people don’t have feelings of denial, which makes them question if they are normally going through grief. Unfortunately, this idea that we have to move through the 5 stages means that many people have a false understanding of how grief works. 

The Truth Behind the 5 Stages

Today, the 5 stages of grief are ubiquitous as a model for all forms of grief. This can be from the loss of a loved one to depression from being laid off. However, the Kubler-Ross model was not intended to be a catch-all for feelings of grief. Rather, it was formed from an understanding of how her psychiatry patients responded to being diagnosed with terminal or life-threatening illnesses. It was not supposed to be applied to all forms of grieving. Dr. Kubler-Ross was known to dislike the misunderstanding this formula caused, even discussing it before her passing in 2004. 

Expanding How We Interpret Grief

While there are some consistencies in the model with some of the feelings people experience during grief, some specialists consider the concept to “box in” some grievers. They might feel like they aren’t “grieving right” if they aren’t feeling the different stages. However, grief is not linear. And it can be experienced in a lot of different ways. A lot of the time, it takes the form of anxiety and stress. It can be deeply depressing, at times. Sometimes, grieving can mean pushing aside your pain to care for others hurting around you. 
Ultimately, there is no one way to grieve. While the 5 stages can make grief seem like a simple process, it just isn’t that straightforward. Overall, you just need to take grief as it comes and seek help when you need it. 

Continuing Education on Grief

There is much we just don’t know about the human mind. The psychiatric field is ever-growing and expanding our understanding of how the brain works, and how we process emotions such as grief. Because of this, we know that there isn’t just one path toward coming to terms with a loss. Many people feel some of the 5 stages while processing grief, but it isn’t a set rule to how to grieve. As discussed above, it is a model that has been deeply misinterpreted and misunderstood in our culture as a whole. And while it may still have a place in discussions about feelings of grief, it generally should not be regarded as a roadmap for loss. Overall, people have a hard enough time with the stress of losing a loved one to worry if they are fitting into the mold of “how to grieve.”

 

The author of this post is not a professional therapist or counselor. For assistance in finding a grief counselor that is right for you, there are several resources out there. For our Grief Resource Center, written by Dr. Bill Webster, click here. 
For over 50 years, Matthew Funeral Home has been serving the Staten Island community. We can help with almost every aspect of your loved one’s memorial service. Our family is here to serve yours, every step of the way.

Leave a comment
Name*:
Email:
Comment*:
Please enter the numbers and letters you see in the image. Note that the case of the letters entered matters.

Comments

Please wait

Previous Posts

Grief and Dealing With Suicide

When faced with the loss of a loved one, the grief can be devastating. But when a loved one takes their own life, the grief that families feel afterward can often be complicated. According to the A...

Sunlight and Combatting Grief

As the weather gets warmer and summer is on the horizon, it is time for many people to schedule vacations and weekend outings. For people dealing with grief and depression, it may seem difficult to...

Grief and Selfishness

Grief is a complex emotional state. For many people, grief can bring out different sides of us. And while grief is not an excuse to act out, or be a bad person, it can often be a defense mechanism....

The First Mother's Day Without Her

Mother’s Day is a time we celebrate those who devoted their lives to caring for us, and for bringing us into the world. But it can also be a solemn reminder after the passing of your mother. The lo...

Can I be Both Cremated and Buried?

While most people assume you have to choose between burial or cremation at the end of life, there are more options available. One is to choose both. You can choose burial and cremation together. Be...

Retiring In Stages

Retiring at 65 has been a common aspect of the American lifestyle for generations, but full retirement at that age may not be in the cards for everyone. With costs of living consistently on the ris...

Funeral Planning for the LGBTQ+ Community

When it comes to end-of-life services, it is important to have a plan in order. This can be especially true for many LGBTQ+ people. In the event of your passing, your wishes should be upheld for yo...

Identifying Signs of A Stroke

Stroke is a leading cause of death in the US, killing 1 person in America every 3.5 minutes. The risk of stroke can increase as you age. For the safety of you and your loved ones, it is important t...

Donating Your Body To Science

Body donation is a process that very few Americans decide to participate in. But, it is a practice that can lead to advances in medical science, improved medical training procedures, and more. This...

Using Coping Mechanisms for Grief

When you hear the term “Coping Mechanism,” it is often in a negative context. However, that is not always the case. Coping mechanisms can help you deal with the short-term effects of grief. When us...